I sent this to G+ Feedback. I feel better now.
Subject: Custom G+ URL.
A few months ago, I got an email for a pre-approved custom G+ URL. It suggested JorgWillekens as I used my real name G+. I didn’t want that, but asked for the name I am known on the internet for (Hell, I own the .com, .org, .net and .eu) which is “jawtheshark”. To my knowledge there is nobody else on the Internet using that nickname, and I’ve been using it at least since 1998.
Today, I got this nickname denied. I do not approve of this, and I’m pretty certain it’s just your system that is making stupid blanket assumptions. It doesn’t stop there. Due to the forced integration of YouTube, I renamed myself to “Jaw The Shark” because youtube became useless with its native accounts (which, *surprise*, was “jawtheshark”… Check, it, I know you can!)
Now, the custom URL suggests JawTheShark to me, but I absolutely need to add a suffix. You’d think, it would be clear to such a big data-mining operation as you, as what account is what person. My suspicion is that it’s not allowed because it exists as a youtube account or because I tried getting it before.
Now, comes the kicker, back in the day, I created a serious GMail aptly named “jorg.willekens”. It’s used mainly for email, but obviously it has a G+ account as you always get the whole package with Google. I was curious whether I could get JorgWillekens custom URL on that one. Guess what? I can’t: I need to add a suffix. My best guess is, because of my other account.
The TL;DR version for you:
- The account email@example.com can’t get the custom URL “JorgWillekens”
- The account firstname.lastname@example.org can’t get the custom URL “JawTheShark”, but can get “JorgWillekens”.
- The custom URL “JawTheShark” is, for some bizarre reason, not available at all.
How effed-up is that, I ask you? Especially, that the person behind these accounts is one and the same, and you undoubtedly know that or you should really hire some better data-miners.
That’s all I have to say. I’m pretty sure, you are not interested in my ramblings.
For the record: Facebook had no qualms in giving a custom URL “jawtheshark” and LinkedIn’s custom URL knows me as “willekens”. Notice the difference between usage? I’ll give a hint: private use versus professional use.
You want me to use G+ or not, because more and more, I have the impression that the message is “Use FaceBook for crying out loud, the social thing is just a fad!”
Jorg “jawtheshark” Willekens
(Also published to my blog, and all social network sites I operate on)